For anyone considering cirBTC as a way to hold Bitcoin exposure on Ethereum, the key question is which safeguards depend on Circle and its contracts rather than on-chain protections.
In a technical assessment posted to Aave’s governance forum and reported on November 10, 2026, Aave Labs said Circle’s wrapped Bitcoin token met the technical conditions for listing on Aave’s Ethereum market. The assessment was not an announcement that cirBTC had been listed.
Circle issues cirBTC with a target of 1:1 Bitcoin reserves. At the time of the assessment, approximately 910.15 cirBTC, worth about $70.12 million, was in circulation on Ethereum mainnet.
Aave Labs also identified trust-boundary concerns: contract upgrades, transfer pauses and address freezes were each controlled by a single key, with no on-chain timelock. An audit report for the Cross-Chain Token Service (CCTS) framework, which can mint cirBTC on Ethereum, had not been provided. Reserve-proof data had repeatedly reported reserves below supply, but Aave Labs said the reason could not be determined from on-chain information. Those reports alone do not establish why the discrepancy occurred.